Playing to win or playing to participate. Which is right depends on the stage a team has reached, and I do not have a settled answer yet. On day 2169 of my daily barefoot-style run vlog, I worked through the question out loud. Here is where I have got to so far.
Saturday is football day. My youngest son's team plays in Division 1 and finished second in the league. This morning they beat one of the sides competing with them for second place. Three players on the opposing side used to play for my son's team. They left for what I would call elite teams, where winning matters more than anything else. Our lads beat them. Players leave for their own reasons, so I do not read the result as proof of anything. I did notice how differently people prioritise things.
Then my under-15s played. We sit mid-table in Division 3 and faced a side nearer the bottom. We were 4-0 down at half-time. The lads fought in the second half and won it 3-2, but we lost the match 6-3. The damage came in the first half, and the effort in that half was not what I ask for.
My under-15s have always been mostly local lads who have played together for years. We have some strong players and some developmental players. We kept a local-first approach because we are a village team. A few families have moved into the area, which puts their sons inside our catchment. We did not poach anyone. Some of these boys are friends with our better players.
Next season is under-16s. For these boys it is their GCSE year and their final year of colts football. After that comes men's football, if they want to carry on. Next season will likely be the last one I coach this group alongside my fellow coach.
Two strong lads want to join us. Both are local and both know the group from school, so the chemistry would not be disrupted. Most of the players want them in. The cost falls on a couple of the weaker players who have stayed with us throughout.
I have always played to win. Many of my players do too. They enjoy football more when they win and less when they lose, which is natural.
This group is also a brotherhood. Years together built it, and participation built it. Some of our strongest players were once among our weakest. We developed them. Participation is not the opposite of winning here. For this squad, participation is where the winners came from, and I do not want to lose this.
My one requirement as a coach has always been simple. Try your hardest and have fun. Several times this season the lads have let us down on effort. Players with experience at a higher level will bring work rate and standards to training and matches, and I hope the rest follow.
My gut says give these boys a chance to win something in their final year. Add the two players. Keep every current player in the squad, because we would never remove anyone. Rotate game time, and be honest about the reason. We would not go up or down this season, but we would be in a position to strengthen and challenge in the league next year.
I am torn, though, and I will not decide alone. My fellow coach and I will sit down, and we will ask the players what they think before we choose.
The right answer depends on the stage. Early on, participation builds the base, the friendships and the habit of turning up. In a final year, boys who have given ten years of their Saturdays have earned a chance to aim at something. I believe both are true together. The skill lies in being fair to the players who give up minutes, and I think those players should hear the reasoning from us directly.
My streak sits between the two ideas. Running every day is participation. I show up whether the run feels good or poor. Yet the goal is a win: 40,075km, a lap of the world, run barefoot style. Today is day 2169. I have covered 16,647.40km, which leaves 23,427.60km. No single day delivers the goal. Showing up daily builds the distance, and showing up daily is how the mission finishes. I am planning around a streak of roughly 16.5 years, so consistency has to outrank intensity.
Children are the reason behind all of this. The vlog is part of a fundraiser for children's causes, with a target of £1M. Coaching keeps me close to how young people feel when they are picked and when they are left out. Whatever the team decides, I want the process to be fair to every boy in the squad.
If you coach or play, I would like to hear how you weigh winning against participation. Leave a comment. If you back the mission, subscribe and share the vlog. The more people who watch, the more is raised for children's causes.
Watch the full episode: https://youtu.be/356DRZiB30A





